Love with an expiration date: The Valentine's Day "trigger" between windows of tolerance and primary relational wounds

Edited by: Alice Russo, Elisa Ninvaggi, Federica Ruffini, Federico Maroli, Francesca Candus, Giulia Trovato, Massimo Lattanzi, and Tiziana Calzone.

Organizations: Italian Association of Psychology and Criminology (AIPC), Italian Center for Relational Psychotraumatology (CIPR), National Observatory on Family Homicide (ONOF).

Abstract

This study analyzes the impact of Valentine’s Day on the emotional stability of a sample of young adults, investigating how the social obligation of affective celebration can act as an aversive stimulus. The data reveals a stratification of distress: while younger men (aged 18-24) show greater vulnerability to social conditioning and the duty of the "reparative gift," the female population aged 25-30 exhibits the highest resonance with primary relational wounds and a sense of social inadequacy.

Introduction

From a relational psychotraumatology perspective, this holiday tends to narrow the "Window of Tolerance" of subjects, particularly in those with a history of C-PTSD. This contraction of the emotional processing space can lead to marked dysregulation, manifesting through irritability and a potential loss of impulse control. The results suggest the need for specialized clinical approaches—such as those documented by CIPR and AIPC—aimed at mitigating the impact of relational trauma and preventing severe acting-out, which is often fueled by a distorted perception of familiarity and social expectations.

In relational psychotraumatology and criminological profiling, the degree of familiarity represents a fundamental qualifying variable. By emphasizing couple bonds, Valentine's Day exposes the quality of this familiarity. For those in dysfunctional relationships, the holiday is not a celebration but a stress activator that can exacerbate the loss of impulse control.

Listen to the podcast on the AIPC Editore Spotify Channel, MENTE|CRIMINE|TRAUMA: “Love with an Expiration Date: The Valentine's Day 'trigger' between windows of tolerance and primary relational wounds.” Click the link: https://open.spotify.com/episode/2uYSd4fOUdGhk81l1GgAim?si=VL-czOIbR2-2kSb3_rsw4Q

Descriptive Analysis of Results

The data analysis highlights a progression of emotional and social burden linked to age and gender.

• Men (18-24 years): A mean score of 7.50 defines a profile at the edge of balance, strongly characterized by Social Conditioning (3.75). In this group, the holiday is experienced primarily as a "commercial automatism" and a duty to avoid judgment, though emotional regulation appears preserved.
• Men (25-30 years): A score of 7.60 shows a slight increase in Emotional Reactivity (ER 3.68), which is compensated by a lower perceived pressure from external conditioning compared to the younger group.
• Women (18-24 years): The situation is more complex (score 8.40), with a peak in Emotional Regulation issues (3.90), indicating that the holiday acts as a trigger that narrows the window of tolerance, leading to states of anxiety or pressure.
• Women (25-30 years): This group presents the highest score (9.12), falling firmly into the Conditioned Profile. This group shows the greatest vulnerability regarding Primary Wounds and Relational Trauma (2.16), signaling that the recurrence forcefully reactivates feelings of inadequacy and pain linked to past abandonment.

Download the article slides: [Link to AIPC Slides]

Emotional Dysregulation and the Window of Tolerance

Data indicates that women between 25 and 30 show significant resonance with past relational wounds. Clinically, this translates into a very narrow Window of Tolerance, as documented by research from CIPR, ONOF, and AIPC. When social expectations exceed the subject's self-regulation capacity, severe acting-out occurs: irritability and pressure transform into a loss of impulse control, where the "action" (acting-out) replaces the processing of pain.

The Weight of Trauma and Social Conditioning

While young men (18-24) seem more subject to "superficial" social conditioning, the weight of relational trauma and shame emerges in women of the older bracket. The sense of "being wrong" if alone or uncelebrated reactivates C-PTSD (Complex Trauma), where the present is overwritten by past rejections. In these cases, the gift or celebration takes on a distorted reparative function, in a desperate attempt to stabilize a fragmented relational identity.

Conclusions

The analysis suggests that Valentine's Day can represent a risk to the psychological stability of those with unresolved traumatic experiences. It is essential to recognize the signs of dysregulation before they escalate into acting-out. The Italian Center for Relational Psychotraumatology (CIPR) offers specialized approaches to support healing from relational trauma, integrating advanced methodologies such as biofeedback to widen the window of tolerance and restore balance.

Support Contacts:

• Email: aipcitalia@gmail.com
• WhatsApp: +39 3924401930 (Daily 11:00 AM – 4:00 PM CET)
• Website: www.associazioneitalianadipsicologiaecriminologia.it
• Tax Code (CF): 97238660589

© 2026 AIPC Editore – All Rights Reserved. Partial or total use of this material is prohibited without mandatory citation of the source for any medium (online, print, video, audio, reports, and publications). Violations will be prosecuted according to the law.